Lady Justice Statue
A professor in the UK asked for greater scrutiny in rape cases as she believes that the court may undermine such cases. Sang Hyun Cho/Pixabay Royalty-Free

The UK government's independent adviser on rape has called for greater scrutiny of how complainants are treated during sexual offence trials in England and Wales, warning that improvements in police investigations have not been fully reflected in court proceedings.

Professor Katrin Hohl, in an interview with The Guardian on Sunday, November 15, wants closer examination of the conduct of barristers, judges, and juries, particularly the influence of their misconceptions about rape and sexual assault in cases.

Adviser Warns of Gap Between Investigations and Trials

Hohl has helped shape reforms through Operation Soteria, an initiative designed to shift police investigations towards suspects' conduct rather than placing disproportionate scrutiny on complainants. The approach has informed changes in policing and the Crown Prosecution Service (CPS), but Hohl has raised concerns about whether those improvements continue when cases reach court.

In October 2026, Hohl warned that cases prepared under the revised investigative approach could encounter a 'cliff edge' at trial, where courtroom practices may undermine progress made during investigations.

Her latest intervention, reported on 15 November 2026, called for closer examination of how rape and sexual assault trials operate, including the questioning of complainants, judicial directions and the treatment of evidence.

The Ministry of Justice has already commissioned Hohl to research how Operation Soteria principles are applied in court, as confirmed in the government's October response to the Independent Review of the Criminal Courts.

Russell Brand Trial Raises Questions Over Rape Myths

The calls for greater scrutiny follow Russell Brand's criminal trial at Southwark Crown Court.

Brand was convicted of one rape and three sexual assaults involving four women. He was sentenced to 10 years and six months in prison on 9 November 2026. He was separately acquitted of two rape charges and one attempted indecent assault charge.

Six additional women have also made allegations of sexual misconduct against Brand. These include allegations of non-consensual sexual activity, sexual assault and coercive behaviour.

During the trial, Brand's defence barrister, Ian Winter KC, questioned the complainants' accounts, referring to whether they had resisted, screamed, or attempted to leave. The arguments prompted criticism from Victims' Commissioner Claire Waxman, who challenged assumptions about how people respond to sexual violence.

Waxman has called for judges to be legally required to address rape myths when they arise during trials and to provide appropriate directions to juries. Justice Secretary Alex Norris has also written to the Bar Standards Board, requesting consideration of standards for barristers representing defendants accused of rape and other sexual offences.

Ministers Consider Changes to Age-of-Consent Law

Ministers are separately considering calls for a staggered age-of-consent framework that would restrict sexual relationships between adults above a specified age and 16- or 17-year-olds.

The proposal follows a campaign by Mia Latter, who alleges Brand raped her when she was 16 and he was 30. Latter has publicly identified herself and called for changes to the law. Her allegations are separate from the offences for which Brand was convicted and have not been established in court.

Work and Pensions Secretary Pat McFadden said on 15 November 2026 that ministers would discuss the proposed changes. Speaking on the BBC's Sunday with Laura Kuenssberg, McFadden acknowledged that questions surrounding a staggered age of consent had been raised but did not announce a government decision or legislative timetable.

Rape Crisis Services Report Fourfold Increase in Calls

Rape Crisis England & Wales has reported increased demand for specialist support following Brand's conviction and other publicised allegations of sexual misconduct.

Chief executive Ciara Bergman said calls to the organisation's 24-hour rape and sexual abuse support line had quadrupled since the beginning of November. Specialist centres have also reported increased demand from people seeking assistance after encountering coverage of sexual violence and abuse.

The Ministry of Justice said it was pursuing changes intended to prevent irrelevant evidence based on rape myths from being used against complainants. The government is also rolling out specialist courtrooms for rape and serious sexual offences and investing £550 million over three years in services supporting victims and witnesses.

Although research into the application of Operation Soteria principles in court has already been commissioned, Hohl is calling for broader scrutiny of courtroom practices.