Art Gallery
Van Gogh’s £136 million painting faces a Nazi-era provenance dispute ahead of its Sotheby’s auction Miguel González/Pexels

A Vincent van Gogh painting estimated at $180 million (£136 million) is at the centre of a dispute after descendants of its former Jewish owners asked Sotheby's to withdraw it from a New York auction. The Fischer family heirs argue that the painting may have been sold in 1936 under financial pressure linked to Nazi persecution.

Châtaigniers en fleurs, also known as Blossoming Chestnut Trees, is scheduled to be offered on Wednesday, 18 November, as part of Sotheby's Blaquier-Arrieta Collection sale. The heirs question whether their family was genuinely free to sell the work. Sotheby's says its research has not established that the transaction was made under duress, but discussions with the family are continuing.

Why the Fischer Family Is Challenging the Sale

The painting was acquired in 1909 by Samuel Fischer, a prominent German publisher and founder of S. Fischer Verlag. Following his death in 1934, it passed to his daughter Brigitte and her husband, Gottfried Bermann Fischer, who took over the publishing business.

As the Nazi regime tightened restrictions on Jewish people and cultural life, the publishing house came under increasing pressure. Authors associated with it faced bans, while Bermann Fischer left Berlin for Vienna in an effort to continue publishing their work.

The heirs argue that the family's financial circumstances were shaped by Nazi persecution and that this pressure may have influenced the decision to sell the painting. Their lawyer has also pointed to the Reich Flight Tax, which Jewish people leaving Germany were required to pay and which the family says added to its financial burden.

The Crucial 1936 Transaction

The painting was deposited with art dealer Walter Feilchenfeldt in Amsterdam in 1932 or 1933 before being sold to Paris-based collectors Henriette and Marcel Kapferer in 1936. The heirs argue that Nazi persecution and financial pressures, including the costs of leaving Germany, may have prevented the family from making a free choice.

Their Berlin-based lawyer, Gunnar Schnabel, has challenged Sotheby's to establish that the painting was sold at fair market value and that the family would have sold it regardless of Nazi rule. In a letter dated 12 November, reported by The New York Times, Schnabel warned that, without such evidence, 'no auction may take place'.

He also proposed a resolution under the 1998 Washington Principles, non-binding guidelines for addressing claims involving Nazi-era art. No evidence cited in the available reporting establishes that the painting was confiscated, and no court has ruled that the 1936 sale was forced.

Sotheby's Responds to the Claim

Sotheby's says it has researched the painting's ownership history but has not established that the 1936 transaction took place under duress. In a statement, the auction house said: 'While our research to date has not established that the painting was sold under duress, we recognise the importance of engaging thoughtfully and constructively with the family and are committed to working toward a mutually satisfactory resolution'.

Sotheby's has not publicly confirmed that it will withdraw the painting. As of 16 November, its official auction listing continues to include the work in the 18 November sale. The outcome of discussions with the heirs remains unresolved.

The Painting's Ownership After 1936

After the Kapferers acquired the painting, it later passed to Hollywood producer George 'Buddy' Gard de Sylva in 1945 and subsequently to American collector Harriet Harris-Jonas. Argentine collectors Carlos Pedro Blaquier and Nelly Arrieta de Blaquier acquired the work in 1975.

It remained in their collection and is now being offered as part of the Blaquier-Arrieta Collection at Sotheby's. Van Gogh painted Châtaigniers en fleurs in 1890 in Auvers-sur-Oise, near Paris, during the final months of his life.

Why the Dispute Matters

The case highlights the challenges of assessing art sales made under Nazi persecution, when Jewish families faced discrimination, financial pressure and restrictions. The 1998 Washington Principles encourage governments and institutions to identify Nazi-confiscated art and seek 'just and fair solutions' with former owners or their heirs.

The non-binding guidelines do not determine the outcome of individual claims. The Fischer heirs want Sotheby's to withdraw Châtaigniers en fleurs while the circumstances of its 1936 sale are examined.

Sotheby's maintains that its research has not established a forced sale and says discussions are continuing. With the auction listed for Wednesday, 18 November, the dispute remains unresolved.