
A woman whose mother was killed in a New York murder-suicide has come forward with disturbing allegations against her former stepfather, claiming he sexually assaulted her and created a shrine containing her underwear before fatally shooting his ex-wife.
Allison Pelc accused Norman E. Lohr Jr., 50, of years of harassment and repeatedly violating protection orders. Her mother, Mellissa Pelc-Lohr, 50, was found dead at a residence in Moira, New York, on 27 October 2026. Authorities later found Lohr dead inside his vehicle following an intense police pursuit.
As reported by the New York Post, Allison described the warning signs she believes preceded her mother's death, including alleged sexual violence and stalking. On top of that, she shared footage that she claims shows Lohr entering her personal space and searching through her belongings.
Daughter Alleges Years of Abuse and Disturbing Behaviour
Allison alleged that Lohr raped her in January 2023 and subsequently became obsessed with her. In her video, she described discovering a shrine inside his closet, containing her underwear, other personal items, and liquids.
She claimed the closet had previously housed roughly 100 firearms before Lohr cleared the space for the collection. Other footage she shared allegedly showed him taking her belongings and following her towards her vehicle.
Allison said her mother discovered the shrine and tried to separate from Lohr. The two women also reportedly visited a sheriff's office to report the alleged sexual assault.
According to Allison, she obtained two protection orders in an attempt to feel safe. She alleged that Lohr violated them at least three times without facing meaningful consequences.
A Michigan court hearing concerning a previous alleged violation was reportedly scheduled for 28 October, just one day after Mellissa's death. The allegations have raised troubling questions about the protections Allison and her mother sought before the tragedy.
Police Confirm Homicide and Suicide After Pursuit
New York State Police responded to a residence on South Woods Road in Moira on the morning of 27 October, where they discovered Mellissa dead from gunshot wounds.
Investigators subsequently identified a red Chevrolet Silverado potentially connected to the homicide. Officers located the vehicle in Lyons, more than 200 miles away, but the driver refused to stop.
The pursuit ended after deputies deployed tyre-deflation devices and the vehicle left the roadway. When authorities approached, they found Lohr dead from a self-inflicted gunshot wound.
A Family Left Seeking Answers
Mellissa's tragic death came shortly after she returned from celebrating Allison's 30th birthday in Las Vegas. What should have remained a happy family memory has instead become one of their final celebrations together.
A GoFundMe fundraiser established to help the family with funeral and travel expenses describes her murder as an act of stalking-related domestic violence. So far, the fundraiser has raised nearly 5,000 USD out of its 50,000 USD goal. The page features photos of Mellissa with her children and a heartbreaking description, which partly stated: 'During this incredibly difficult time, we are reaching out to friends, family, our community, and even kind strangers to ask for help supporting Allison and Freddie.'
Mellissa leaves behind her daughter, Allison, and her son, Freddie. In tributes shared after the killing, Allison reportedly said she was struggling to accept that her mother would never return home. Her account also raises a question that extends beyond this family's tragedy: what happens when people report threats, document alleged abuse, and seek legal protection, yet no adequate protection is provided?












