Andrew Shue and Marilee Fiebig are engaged. The pair connected after their former spouses, Amy Robach and T.J. Holmes, made national headlines in late 2022 for their workplace romance. Shue proposed in spring 2026, and the couple kept the milestone private for several months before confirming the engagement with PEOPLE on 21 October.
When the Good Morning America scandal first broke, Shue and Fiebig were the spouses left navigating the public fallout, though both couples had already separated before reports emerged. Now planning a future together, Shue admits he is as surprised as anyone by how their story turned out.
How the Andrew Shue Engagement Came Together
Shue and Robach finalised their divorce in March 2023, and Holmes and Fiebig followed that October, seven months later. Both divorces were settled within a single year of the scandal breaking. By December, Shue and Fiebig had gone public, bonding over shared experiences and leaning on each other through the media storm. By the time the engagement emerged, their relationship had been public for nearly three years.
The pair quietly moved in together in early 2025, spending two years integrating a blended family that includes Shue's three adult sons—Nate, Aidan, and Wyatt—and Fiebig's 13-year-old daughter, Sabine. While Robach and Holmes launched a public podcast to address their relationship, Shue and Fiebig chose total privacy, keeping their family off camera.
Amy Robach and T.J Holmes’ exes, Andrew Shue and Marilee Fiebig, are dating — Page Six reports. pic.twitter.com/Qv4M3s1476
— Buzzing Pop (@BuzzingPop) December 5, 2023
Where Amy Robach and T.J. Holmes Stand Now
Robach and Holmes have moved forward, too. After announcing their engagement on their podcast, Amy & T.J., in October 2025, the former co-anchors married in a private Arkansas ceremony on 19 September, according to reports. Their wedding came less than a year after that announcement, which means both couples reached major relationship milestones within weeks of each other.
The symmetry is striking. The two spouses, once left in the wake of a scandal, have ended up in the same place as their exes: happily committed and starting over. The key difference is volume. Where Robach and Holmes broadcast their romance to a podcast audience, Shue and Fiebig waited months before choosing a single magazine interview to confirm their news.
Shue's Quote About the 'Happy Ending'
Speaking to PEOPLE, Shue skipped any rehearsed backstory and focused on the present. 'I don't know how it happened, but there's a happy ending,' he said, adding that he and Fiebig are 'happy and grateful' for how their lives unfolded.
Reflecting on the personal growth required to reach this point, Shue noted that navigating the public split forced him to work through 'a lot of pain, a lot of struggle, and a lot of humility' before finding stability again. He described the transition as learning to move 'from a need to giving,' calling that shift the core of his connection with Fiebig.
Andrew Shue and Marilee Fiebig Are Engaged: ‘There’s a Happy Ending’ (Exclusive) https://t.co/TiLPTveWVy
— People (@people) October 21, 2026
By holding their spring engagement until late October, Shue and Fiebig ensured they controlled their own narrative rather than reacting to media speculation. What began as a chaotic public fallout has settled into a quiet, grounded future together. With no wedding date announced, the Andrew Shue engagement stands as a rare celebrity story where everyone involved has moved on and found their own version of a happy ending.
