Blake Lively in It Ends With Us
Blake Lively's wardrobe as Lily Bloom in It Ends With Us faces renewed criticism over its unusual mix of workwear and designer fashion @itendswithusmovie/Instagram

Blake Lively's wardrobe in It Ends With Us is back under the fashion microscope, and apparently, Lily Bloom's outfits still haven't grown on everyone. More than two years after the film's release, Reddit users are revisiting the character's oversized overalls, mismatched layers, and expensive designer accessories. Some believe the florist looked less like an everyday working woman and more like someone cosplaying their idea of what 'lower class' looks like.

A discussion on the r/ItEndsWithLawsuits subreddit attracted thousands of upvotes after someone described Lively's costume choices as 'atrocious'. The accompanying photographs showed Lily wearing baggy Carhartt overalls, a blue denim jumpsuit, and a colourful patchwork ensemble, among other outfits that were not exactly receiving flowers from the fandom.

The criticism wasn't simply about whether the clothes looked good. Many questioned whether Lily's wardrobe made sense for her character, particularly when practical workwear appeared alongside luxury shoes and handbags. One commenter called the styling 'cosplaying as what she thought a lowerclass normie should look like'. Others wondered how a florist could afford such an extravagant collection. In essence, the reviews were not exactly blooming.

Lily Bloom's Wardrobe Gets Another Dressing-Down

The brown Carhartt overalls attracted particular attention, especially when paired with expensive footwear. While some defended the workwear brand's durability and price, others argued that combining practical clothing with luxury heels made little sense for Lily Bloom.

'How does a FLORIST earn enough to spend $3k on one pair of shoes?' one commenter asked, questioning whether the styling distracted from the character's development. Another described the wardrobe as 'EXPENSIVE blah', while someone else called it 'aggressively mismatched'.

Some viewers felt Lily resembled a gardener or construction worker rather than someone running a flower shop. Others compared the eclectic styling with Carrie Bradshaw's wardrobe in Sex and the City, arguing that designer labels alone don't guarantee a convincing look.

Interestingly, Lively had considerable input into Lily's costumes. In 2024, she revealed that several pieces came from her personal wardrobe, alongside clothes borrowed from husband Ryan Reynolds and friend Gigi Hadid. Costume designer Eric Daman also confirmed that Lively contributed footwear and helped source pieces for the film.

Daman praised her involvement, describing her enthusiasm for costume design as an asset to the production. From a different angle, Redditors wondered whether Lively was overriding the job of the professionals, who probably would've dressed Lily Bloom as someone in the floral industry instead of someone who played a game of fashion roulette.

Remember When Blake Lively Questioned Costume Interviews?

The renewed criticism targeted at her styling choices also brings an older interview back into view. During a 2016 promotional appearance for Café Society, Norwegian journalist Kjersti Flaa asked Lively and co-star Parker Posey about wearing costumes inspired by the 1930s.

Rather than immediately discussing the outfits, which are a central facet of cinema, Lively questioned why female actors were so frequently asked about clothing. 'Everyone wants to talk about the clothes, but I wonder if they would ask the men about the clothes?' she remarked.

The exchange resurfaced in 2024, drawing backlash over Lively's treatment of the interviewer. Earlier in the same conversation, she had responded to Flaa congratulating her on her pregnancy by congratulating the journalist on her own 'little bump', although Flaa wasn't pregnant.

The costume question is especially striking beside Lively's later comments about It Ends With Us. While promoting the film, she enthusiastically described fashion and costume design as storytelling. The contrast between the two conversations offers another angle on the actress's much-discussed relationship with fashion.

The film also became the centre of a high-profile legal dispute between Lively and director/co-star Justin Baldoni, which the parties settled in May 2026. As for Lily Bloom's wardrobe, a sizeable corner of the internet still considers it a crime against fashion. Two years later, the overalls are still on trial, and Reddit's fashion jury isn't ready to acquit.