A woman on a New York street shouted at Coco Jones that she looked 'so freaking Black'. Jones, mid-pose in front of a city bus, answered without dropping the shot. 'I'm Black and I'm proud'.
The encounter took place during New York Fashion Week, which ran in September. Jones included the footage in a vlog posted on Tuesday 20 October, recapping a day of fittings and shows. The singer and actress, who won a Grammy for 'ICU' and played Hilary Banks in Bel-Air, was being photographed on the street ahead of the Tommy Hilfiger show when the heckling started.
The woman reportedly called her disgusting and used a racial slur before the camera moved on. Jones did not take the bait at any point. She thanked the woman, took two more photographs, and blew her a kiss on the way out. As of this week, she had not commented on the incident publicly.
Five Words, and Then Back to Work
What makes the clip travel is how little room Jones gives it. There is no speech, no confrontation, no turning the camera round. There is one line, delivered flat, and a return to the job she was there to do.
That restraint is also what made the clip contentious once it reached a celebrity gossip forum, where it climbed fast and set off a long argument about what composure costs.
Black Women Said They Recognised It
Much of the response was not about Jones at all. It came from Black women saying they had done the same thing many times.
'It's kinda what we have to do daily as black women', one commenter wrote. 'It suck's just having to smile and keep going when it genuinely hurts'. A reply picked up the double bind: 'And if we react or defend ourselves we're "angry black women".' Another agreed and added that it was exhausting.
Comment
by u/Ok_Wolfie_11 from discussion
in Fauxmoi
A third described the calculation she had settled on, which was to stop expecting a good outcome. There was no winning whatever she did, she wrote, so she surrounded herself with good people and arranged her life to avoid the rest. Someone else pointed out that staying silent carries its own penalty, since not reacting gets you called stuck up.
One commenter recommended bell hooks's Ain't I a Woman and quoted a passage on how praising Black women's strength can obscure what is actually being endured. Enduring something, hooks argues, is not the same as overcoming it.
Not Everyone Wanted to Celebrate the Composure
The sharpest objection was aimed at the applause rather than at Jones. One commenter asked why the people behaving this way were not the story, instead of the person who took the higher road.
Pressed on it, she went further. Being the bigger person in the face of abuse protects the person doing it, she argued, and emboldens them. 'No one, especially black women should have to be the "bigger person" or kind in the face of abuse'. She described being exhausted by an expectation set on Black women since childhood.
Others wanted a different ending altogether. One wished Jones had turned the camera on the woman and let the world see who was shouting.
None of that is a criticism of how Jones handled it. It is an argument about what the rest of us do with the footage afterwards, and whether calling a response graceful quietly asks for the same grace next time.
