
Actor Noah Schnapp has faced fresh criticism online after joking about auditioning for Haymitch Abernathy in The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping. The Stranger Things actor shared an Instagram Story showing himself with blonde hair, but his post quickly brought back questions about his past comments and actions during the Israel-Gaza conflict.
Some social media users questioned why Schnapp would joke about playing a character linked to a fight against an unfair system, given the backlash he faced over his past support for Israel. Others shared strong reactions, with one critic writing, 'A zionist wanting to play as a freedom fighter...omg.'
Noah Schnapp's Audition Joke
Schnapp shared the Instagram Story on 21 November, showing himself with blonde hair and a caption that read, 'POV: my audition for haymitch🤣🤣 @josephzada think they picked right for this one'. He tagged Joseph Zada, the actor who plays the younger Haymitch in the new film. The post appeared to be a joke about the casting rather than a serious announcement that he had tried out for the part.
A zionist wanting to play as a freedom fighter…omg https://t.co/Qx5LdXYVda
— ˗ˋˏ Maria Rose ᰔᩚ ˎˊ˗ (@VirtualWhimsy) November 22, 2026
Zada was officially announced as Haymitch in April 2025, alongside Whitney Peak as Lenore Dove Baird. The film, The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping, was released on 20 November 2026, one day before Schnapp shared his Story. Zada was chosen to lead the story as the young version of the well-known character.
The new film follows Haymitch as he enters the 50th Hunger Games, also known as the Second Quarter Quell. He becomes part of a fight against the Capitol, the powerful government that controls the districts and forces young people to compete in deadly games. This story has become a major point in the online debate, with critics connecting its themes of power and resistance to Schnapp's past political controversy.
Why His Gaza Stance Returned
The criticism against Schnapp goes back to November 2023, when a video of him with friends holding stickers that read 'Zionism is sexy' and 'Hamas is ISIS' spread online. The clip led to calls for a boycott of Stranger Things and strong reactions from people who disagreed with the message. His actions became a subject of debate as the war in Gaza continued.
Noah Schnapp on his thoughts about Israel-Palestine:
— Pop Crave (@PopCrave) January 16, 2024
“My thoughts and beliefs have been so far misconstrued from anything even close to what I believe... I only want peace and safety and security for all innocent people affected by this conflict.” pic.twitter.com/tWkvfxxQoi
In January 2024, the actor addressed the backlash in a video shared on TikTok. He said his thoughts and beliefs had been 'misconstrued' and explained that he wanted peace and safety for innocent people affected by the conflict. He also said he had spoken with friends from Palestinian backgrounds and had learned from those talks.
are we gonna forget that noah schnapp is a zionist who ignores thousands of palestinians being killed by israel? https://t.co/N1ARc1tfHi pic.twitter.com/Ig4qHwyvtt
— ivefalleninhatewithyou 🇵🇸🇨🇩🇸🇩🇱🇧🇮🇷 (@stravvberrys0da) November 27, 2025
Schnapp also spoke about the need to bring Israeli hostages home and end the loss of innocent lives in Palestine. He said he stood against the killing of innocent people and hoped Israelis and Palestinians could live together in peace. His response came as he faced strong online criticism over his earlier actions.
Fans Question His Character
After his Haymitch joke spread online, some users brought up the old controversy and questioned whether Schnapp was a good fit for the character. One post read, 'A zionist wanting to play as a freedom fighter...omg.' Another user compared the actor's past controversy with the story's themes, arguing that his actions did not match the character's fight against oppression.
Other critics also pointed to Haymitch's role in standing against the Capitol. They argued that the character represents people who fight against a powerful system that controls and harms others. For these users, Schnapp joking about playing the character brought back an issue they had not forgotten.
However, not all reactions focused on his political views. Some viewers simply joked about his blonde look and said Zada was the right choice for the role. Others also pointed out that Schnapp's use of 'POV' made it clear that his post was meant as a joke, not proof of a real audition.














