
A rape survivor's decision to reunite with the man who sexually assaulted her and eventually co-write a book with him has left Reddit users questioning what they are looking at. The unusual story of Icelandic writer Thordis Elva and Australian man Tom Stranger resurfaced in a November 2026 online discussion. Social media users reacted with disbelief to the pair's decision to share a platform and recount the experience together.
The Reddit post, titled 'The fuck?', was shared in the r/Caldruki community and featured an image of Elva and Stranger appearing together with the caption: 'A rape survivor and her rapist team up to tell their story together.'
While the entire story sounds like something made up for an internet joke, the pair have publicly discussed their history in a TED Talk and a jointly written book. The circumstances behind their reunion, however, are considerably more complicated than the viral caption suggests.
Comment
by u/Quiet-Taste6712 from discussion
in Caldruki
Thordis Elva Was 16 When Tom Stranger Raped Her
Elva was 16 when she met Stranger, an 18-year-old Australian exchange student who was studying in Iceland. The two were dating at the time, but their relationship took a traumatic turn after a school dance in 1996.
According to their account, Elva had become heavily intoxicated during the evening. Stranger took her home, where he sexually assaulted her. The experience left her struggling with shame, confusion and the psychological consequences of the attack.
Elva initially struggled to identify what had happened as rape. She had believed sexual violence was something committed by strangers rather than someone she knew and considered her boyfriend. She also did not report the assault to authorities at the time.
The two eventually went their separate ways, but the experience continued to affect Elva long after the relationship ended. In 2005, nine years after the assault, she contacted Stranger through email. She wanted him to understand the damage his actions had caused and initially expected him to deny what had happened.
Instead, Stranger acknowledged his responsibility for the assault. Their exchange developed into years of correspondence, eventually leading to an agreement to meet face-to-face.
Comment
by u/Quiet-Taste6712 from discussion
in Caldruki
She Travels To Meet Her Attacker 16 Years Later
In 2013, Elva travelled from Iceland to Cape Town, South Africa, where she met Stranger, who had travelled from Australia. The meeting was not an ordinary reunion between former partners. It involved two people confronting an incident that had shaped their lives in dramatically different ways.
Their conversations became the foundation for South of Forgiveness: A True Story of Rape and Responsibility, a book they co-wrote and published in 2017. The memoir explored the assault, Stranger's eventual acknowledgement of his actions and Elva's personal process of confronting the trauma. It also examined the difficult conversations surrounding responsibility, shame, forgiveness and the consequences of sexual violence.
Stranger's participation in the project was particularly controversial because it meant giving the man responsible for the assault a public platform alongside the survivor. However, Elva explained that she wanted to challenge the silence surrounding sexual violence and encourage conversations about consent and accountability.
They Appeared Together in a TED Talk
In October 2016, Elva and Stranger took the stage at TEDWomen 2016 in San Francisco to deliver a talk titled Our Story of Rape and Reconciliation. The appearance attracted attention because it placed the survivor and the man who raped her on the same stage, discussing the assault in front of an audience.
During the presentation, Stranger described his actions as rape and acknowledged the harm he had caused. Elva, meanwhile, discussed the years of emotional pain and self-blame that followed the incident. Their decision to speak together also raised questions about whether perpetrators should be given a platform in conversations about sexual violence.
In another interview with TED, Elva acknowledged that she had hesitated over giving Stranger a public voice. However, she explained that she believed listening to people who had committed sexual violence could help others understand the attitudes and behaviour that contribute to abuse. Elva said nobody should be expected to follow their particular path towards reconciliation.
Comment
by u/Tamosauskas from discussion
in ted
Reddit Users Question the Unusual Partnership
The resurfaced Reddit post prompted a mixture of disbelief, criticism and discussion about the decision to reunite. Some commenters questioned why the survivor would give her attacker a platform, while others argued that the decision was ultimately hers to make.
Comment
by u/Tamosauskas from discussion
in ted
One commenter wrote, 'At the end of the day, it's her decision,' while another pushed back against the idea that healing necessarily requires forgiveness.
In her 2017 interview with TED, Elva explained that by the time Stranger acknowledged what he had done, the statute of limitations had expired. She stressed that neither of them believed sexual violence should escape legal consequences. Stranger also did not receive the proceeds from their book, with his share going to a shelter for sexual assault victims in Iceland, according to CBS News.












