Mariah Carey Barbie
Mattel's new Mariah Carey Holiday Celebration Barbie recreates the singer's iconic Christmas look, although fans are questioning the doll's resemblance to the pop star @barbie/Instagram

Mariah Carey has returned to claim her annual Christmas throne, and Mattel has brought a brand-new Barbie along for the festivities. Unfortunately, the doll's face has left some fans wondering whether the Queen of Christmas accidentally sent Britney Spears or Celine Dion to collect her crown.

Unveiled on Wednesday, 18 November, the latest Mariah Carey Holiday Celebration Barbie recreates the singer's famous Yuletide look from 1994. The collectible features a red velvet Santa Claus outfit with white faux-fur trimming, long blonde hair, and a black belt. There's even a miniature microphone bearing her initials.

The outfit was immediately triggering nostalgia bells, but the facial resemblance was apparently not hitting the mark. A Reddit post showcasing the doll attracted thousands of upvotes as commenters attempted to identify the celebrity staring back at them. Their guesses included Britney Spears, Celine Dion, Kelly Clarkson, and practically everyone except the woman whose name was printed on the box.

Is That Mariah Carey or Britney Spears?

The discussion on r/popculturechat became an unofficial celebrity identification game. 'It's Britney', one commenter declared, referencing Spears' famous introduction. Another agreed that the doll resembled a combination of Spears and Dion, prompting someone to describe it as a 'Britney/Celine morph'.

The Celine Dion comparisons were a huge common denominator. 'That is Celine Dion! Lol', one person wrote.

Then came perhaps the most devastating question of the entire discussion: 'Um, is the Mariah doll in the room with us?'

Some commenters argued that the doll's facial features were too generic. One suggested Mattel had simply added a beauty mark to an ordinary Barbie, while another questioned whether the designers had been 'modeling her based on memories and vibes'.

Not everyone had beef with the doll's features, though. One commenter praised the eye makeup for capturing the singer's familiar look, noting that celebrity Barbies don't always achieve perfect facial likenesses. Another suggested the doll resembled a combination of Carey's early-2000s appearance and her cartoon likeness.

Mariah Carey's Second Barbie Brings Back Her Christmas Look

Despite the online confusion, Mattel's newest creation has plenty of recognisable Mariah details. Officially dubbed as the Barbie Mariah Carey Holiday Celebration Doll #2, the collectible takes inspiration from the artwork associated with her 1994 Christmas album, Merry Christmas, and its timeless hit, 'All I Want for Christmas Is You'.

Designed by Angel Kent, the collectible is priced at $80 and became available on Wednesday, 18 November. This isn't Carey's first doll on the iconic Mattel Barbie shelf. Her original holiday Barbie arrived in 2023, wearing a glittering red gown with a thigh-high slit, and curls with a big personality. That release sold out its initial inventory in less than 24 hours.

For collectors, the new release offers another miniature tribute to one of pop music's most legendary holiday traditions.

Meanwhile, Redditors and their discerning eye for distinguishing one diva from another still wonder exactly who Mattel put in that Santa outfit. Mariah Carey may be all anyone wants for Christmas, but judging by the reactions, fans might need to check the name tag twice.