
Michelle Phan is facing criticism from former fans and animation enthusiasts after news of her planned 50-episode anime series, Kiss & Makeup. The announcement sparked a debate about the use of artificial intelligence in creative work.
The beauty influencer's latest venture has drawn scepticism on Reddit. Commenters questioned whether an AI-assisted production deserves to be presented as an original animated series.
The AI Criticism
The controversy gained traction on Tuesday, 17 November, after a post on Reddit highlighted the project and accused Phan of using AI to produce the anime. The discussion focused on comments from a man identified by the original poster as Andy, who is reportedly involved in the project and appeared to defend its use of technology without directly addressing the AI criticism.
The Reddit post's author questioned why those involved would avoid explicitly acknowledging the use of artificial intelligence. The discussion quickly expanded beyond the production itself, with users debating the value of AI-generated entertainment and whether audiences should support projects that rely on generative tools instead of traditional animation.
Comment
by u/RingHonest7272 from discussion
in BeautyGuruChatter
One commenter questioned why viewers should invest their time in a 50-episode series if its creators had not personally made the artwork. Others argued that the announcement seemed to emphasise the project's scale more than the creative work behind it.
Several users also raised concerns about generative AI's potential impact on professional illustrators and animators. One commenter argued that aspiring artists could have been hired to work on the series instead, while another questioned whether the creators would receive recognition for work produced through automated tools.
Why Is Michelle Phan Facing AI Backlash?
The criticism reflects a wider dispute over generative AI in entertainment, particularly in animation and illustration. Artists have raised concerns about the technology's training data, the potential use of copyrighted material without permission and the risk that companies may replace paid creative work with automated production.
For critics, the issue is not simply whether AI can produce visually appealing images. They argue that animation involves artistic decisions, technical skill, and collaboration among writers, illustrators, animators, voice actors, and other creative professionals. Using generative AI in place of some of those contributions raises questions about credit, compensation and authorship.
The Reddit discussion also highlighted frustration with what users perceived as vague language around the project's production. The original poster specifically criticised Andy's reported response, suggesting the team should be more direct about whether AI was involved.
Comment
by u/RingHonest7272 from discussion
in BeautyGuruChatter
Michelle Phan's Creative Ambitions
Phan became one of YouTube's earliest major beauty creators after building an audience through makeup tutorials and transformation videos. Her work helped popularise online beauty content and eventually led to business ventures beyond her channel.
In 2011, she co-founded Ipsy, the beauty subscription company that became one of the most recognisable businesses associated with online beauty influencers. She also explored storytelling through The Enchantress, a digital comic project that combined fantasy, manga and anime-inspired visuals.
In a 2015 interview with Fast Company, Phan discussed her interest in comics and described how an idea she had developed as a child eventually became a story project. She said art and comic books had been passions since she was young, making her interest in animation and illustrated storytelling a longstanding part of her creative identity.
Comment
by u/RingHonest7272 from discussion
in BeautyGuruChatter
Does AI Belong in Anime Production?
The Reddit thread was largely critical, with some former viewers saying they felt disappointed by the direction Phan had taken. Others connected the announcement to their broader concerns about the commercialisation of generative AI and the pressure it could place on working artists.
Not every comment focused on the technology. Some users revisited Phan's earlier creative projects and questioned how much credit she should receive for work involving other artists. Whether the 50-episode project can win over sceptical viewers may depend on how clearly its creators explain the production process, the role of human artists and the contributions behind the finished series.












