Amber Riley criticises Playbill for apologising only after backlash over the musical listing Gage Skidmore/Wikimedia Commons CC BY-SA 2.0

Amber Riley criticised Playbill on 20 November for issuing an apology only after public backlash to the George Floyd: the Musical casting notice. She argued that the publication should have identified the material as racist before publishing it.

The Glee actress also questioned why organisations wait for scrutiny before acknowledging the nature of the content they support. She added that apologising after the fact fails to address the initial decision to give the project exposure.

Her comments followed Playbill's removal of the listing and its subsequent public apology. In its statement, the publication described the notice as hateful and acknowledged that it should never have appeared on its website.

What Was in the Casting Notice?

The controversy began on Wednesday, 18 November, when Playbill Jobs published a casting notice for George Floyd: The Musical. Busted Broadway, an independent company based in New Jersey, proposed the project as a cast recording.

The listing sought lead rappers with strong hip-hop and spoken-word skills, as well as lead singers. It described the company's productions as provocative, raunchy, and intentionally absurd for the stage.

Playbill casting controversy 'George Floyd: The Musical'

This project quickly drew criticism for its focus on George Floyd, a 46-year-old Black man murdered in Minneapolis on 25 May 2020 after former police officer Derek Chauvin knelt on his neck for over nine minutes during an arrest. His death led to protests across the United States, prompting renewed calls for racial justice and police accountability.

Initially, actress Malynda Hale shared the casting notice and questioned why Playbill accepted the listing. Busted Broadway later defended the project. He explained that it was intended to satirise the surrounding culture rather than to make light of, condone, or mock Floyd's murder

Playbill Issues Apology After Backlash

In response to criticism, Playbill Jobs removed the casting notice and apologized on Thursday, 19 November. The company acknowledged it had mistakenly approved a listing that should not have appeared on its platform. It also committed to reviewing and updating its approval procedures to prevent future incidents.

In its Instagram statement, Playbill wrote, 'Late yesterday afternoon, Playbill Jobs incorrectly approved a job listing that had no place on our site. Once leadership was alerted, the listing was immediately removed, and we began reviewing and revising our approval processes.'

Playbill apologised for amplifying the 'hateful listing' and pledged to strengthen its approval process. It reaffirmed its commitment to supporting the community with 'empathy, consideration, and respect.'

'We know this listing has upset and offended many, and the fact that it made it onto our site has disappointed those who trust us as an outlet,' the statement added. 'For that, we are sorry, and are committed to regaining your trust.'

'Glee' Actor Questions Playbill's Apology

Riley responded in the comments, questioning why the publication addressed the issue only after receiving widespread criticism. The actress wrote, 'I really hate that it's always an apology after outrage but it's never "hmmm this is racist, maybe let's NOT support this in general".'

Playbill later expanded its response beyond removing the listing from its platform. Chairman Philip Birsh and Chief Operating Officer Alex Birsh told Deadline that the company will stop accepting job listings or advertising from Busted Broadway. They added that it will also end coverage of its productions.