Hailey Bieber has admitted that the idea of a threesome might sound exciting in theory, but she would not risk the trust she has built with husband Justin Bieber for the sake of trying one. The model explained that although she understands why some couples might be interested in exploring an arrangement involving a third person, she does not believe it would work for their marriage.
Hailey also shared her belief that crossing that boundary could permanently change their relationship, leaving no way to return to how things were before. Instead, she said she values the strong bond she and Justin have worked hard to build and would not want to jeopardise it for a sexual experiment.
Hailey Opens Up About Threesomes
During an appearance on Alex Cooper's Call Her Daddy podcast, Hailey was asked whether she and Justin had ever tried a threesome, prompting an unusually candid conversation about their private life. She answered no, explaining that the idea could sound appealing without necessarily being something she would want to experience in her own relationship.
'It's funny because I feel like those ideas can be really fun and sound really exciting,' she said, before making her position clear. 'It doesn't work for the two of us,' Hailey added, explaining that an arrangement that suits other couples would not automatically suit her and Justin.
Their Trust Comes First
For Hailey, the biggest concern was not simply the prospect of sharing intimacy with another person, but the possibility of damaging the connection she and Justin had worked hard to develop. She explained that their relationship had reached a place where trust and emotional security mattered too much for her to feel comfortable introducing a third person.
'We've worked very hard to be in this space that we're in now and, like, trusting each other,' she said, describing the bond they had built together. Hailey also made clear that her decision was not about judging everyone who chooses a different relationship arrangement, but about recognising what feels right for her marriage.
Hailey Bieber says sex with a third person might sound exciting, but she believes a threesome with Justin, would destroy the trust they spent years building.
— Kaworu (@kaworu0x) October 26, 2026
“It’s funny because I feel like those ideas can be really fun and, like, sound really exciting.”
“It doesn’t work for… pic.twitter.com/EtEtqTvUDd
Hailey Questions Open Relationships
The model also reflected on couples who choose open relationships, acknowledging that such arrangements can work for some people for a period of time. However, she expressed doubts about whether introducing other partners could ultimately leave a relationship unchanged.
'Some people are in, like, open relationships and, like, it works for a time,' Hailey said, before suggesting that she did not believe the arrangement would necessarily last. She also warned that making the decision to try a threesome could create consequences that a couple could not simply reverse, reinforcing why she would rather avoid the risk.
Justin's Honesty Builds Confidence
Another important part of Hailey's explanation was the openness she said she experienced with Justin, particularly when discussing his past relationships. She described being able to ask him about previous romantic interests without feeling that he needed to hide information from her.
'I could ask him about any person, any past girl, anything and he'd be like, "Oh yeah, like this this this and this,"' she recalled. Hailey said that level of honesty helped strengthen her confidence in their relationship because she felt there was nothing about his past that she did not know.
Her Bedroom Confessions Surprise Fans
The conversation went beyond threesomes, with Cooper asking Hailey about the couple's preferences and what makes intimacy special for them. Hailey revealed that they generally preferred sex at night, although she also enjoyed mornings, and said their preferences were not restricted to one particular position or routine.
She also identified kissing as an important part of physical attraction, explaining that emotional connection played a major role in what made intimacy meaningful to her. When discussing Justin, she suggested that simply lying together and having an enjoyable conversation could also be significant, showing that their connection was not limited to physical attraction.
Online Critics Question Her Comments
Hailey's candid remarks have also prompted criticism from some online commenters, several of whom questioned whether such intimate details should be discussed publicly in the first place. Some described the conversation as inappropriate, while others argued that private matters between spouses should remain behind closed doors.
Why would she even answer something like this? Keep your sex life behind closed doors.
— Sassafrass84 (@Sassafrass_84) October 27, 2026
Why would you ask or answer this question?
— Uweyda (@Uweyda0) October 27, 2026
Disgusting
Other commenters questioned whether discussing the idea of a threesome aligned with their expectations of Christian values, although those reactions reflect individual opinions rather than an objective judgement of Hailey's faith. Her actual comments, meanwhile, focused on her personal boundaries and the importance of trust, rather than an announcement that she or Justin had ever participated in a threesome.
If she truly was a Christian, she wouldn’t even entertain that thought!
— 🌟Diamond 🌟 (@Diamondstar878) October 27, 2026
Ultimately, Hailey's position was straightforward: an idea might sound exciting without being worth the potential consequences for a marriage. For her and Justin, protecting the trust they have built together matters more than experimenting with something she does not feel comfortable pursuing.
